弥合身体活动意向与持续行为之间的差距:证据综述
《Exercise, Sport, and Movement》:Closing the Gap Between Physical Activity Intentions and Sustained Behavior: An Overview of Evidence
【字体:
大
中
小
】
时间:2026年10月01日
来源:Exercise, Sport, and Movement
编辑推荐:
This visual overview of evidence examines the intention–physical activity (I–PA) gap, where positive intentions often fail to translate in
This visual overview of evidence examines the intention–physical activity (I–PA) gap, where positive intentions often fail to translate into behavior, a central challenge in physical activity (PA) promotion. Although intentions are necessary precursors to PA, nearly half of individuals with positive intentions do not follow through, underscoring the importance of identifying predictors of successful intention enactment for theory and practice. Evidence highlights reflective processes (i.e., affective judgments and self-efficacy/perceived control), regulatory processes (i.e., planning and self-monitoring), and reflexive processes (i.e., habit and identity) as key predictors of intention translation. Interventions targeting these constructs as mechanisms of action (MoAs) show small to medium effects on PA, but progress is limited by heterogeneity in behavior-change technique (BCT) application and under-examination of some MoAs. Closing the I–PA gap requires strengthening behavioral regulation, supporting positive affect, and aligning behavior with identity. By synthesizing theory and evidence across four figures, this review illustrates the role of intention in behavioral theories, the I–PA gap, I–PA moderators, and a logic model aligning BCTs with MoAs, offering practical guidance for researchers and practitioners. Future research using sustained experimental designs, including factorial studies, which precisely link BCTs to MoAs will be essential for developing interventions to close the gap between intentions and sustained PA.
INTRODUCTION
A substantial body of evidence consistently demonstrates the extensive physical and mental health benefits associated with regular participation in moderate- or higher-intensity physical activity (PA), including both aerobic PA and muscle-strengthening activities (1). Unfortunately, despite these substantive benefits, one third of adults (and as much as 70% in high-income nations) self-report they do not meet aerobic PA recommendations (2), and even fewer participate in muscle- and bone-strengthening activities (3). PA presents unique challenges compared with other health-related behaviors; it involves initiating rather than stopping a behavior, demands ongoing time and effort, and contains an adaptive physiological response (4). Given both the well-documented advantages and the inherent difficulties in sustaining regular PA, it is unsurprising that many theoretical approaches across several traditions (e.g., social cognitive, humanistic, action control, socioecological, and dual process) have been applied to understanding and changing PA for over half a century (5).
Intention, defined as a decision to perform PA (i.e., decisional intention) and/or the commitment to enact that decision (i.e., intention strength), is a complex construct that occupies a central position in many theories of health-related behavior (6). As Figure 1 illustrates, intention strength is considered the "grand mediator" of behavior in popular theories such as the theory of planned behavior, theory of reasoned action, protection motivation theory, social cognitive theory, and even variants of self-determination theory (e.g., integrated behavior-change model). It also serves as the summary construct for conscious motivation in applications of dual-process models (e.g., habit theory) and variants of action-control models (e.g., health action process approach). Similarly, decisional intention is central to stage models (e.g., the transtheoretical model and precaution adoption process) and other variants of action-control models (e.g., multiprocess action control) (5, 7).
Figure 1. Role of intention in behavioral theories and models. Intention is central to many behavior-change theories, serving as a mediator between upstream influences and behavior, with action-control models extending beyond intention.
There are noteworthy times when intention may not precede a behavior (e.g., spontaneous behaviors, behaviors performed as incidental means of achieving other directives, and behaviors of limited autonomy of choice) (8), yet the pivotal role of intention in the psychology of human behavior cannot be understated. Practically, intention also has a clear role in most initiatives of PA promotion, from recreation programs, to commuting decisions, to PA research and health trials, and clearly all personal change decisions. These theoretical and practical assertions are supported by evidence in intention–PA (I–PA) relations. Specifically, a recent meta-analysis of 23 studies featuring considerable heterogeneity of PA modes and population samples found that engaging in PA without prior intention is unlikely, with only 4% of people reporting no prior intention yet subsequently engaging in PA (9). Thus, the role of intention in understanding PA is well substantiated theoretically, practically, and empirically.
THE CHALLENGE: THE I–PA GAP
Although intention plays a pivotal role in PA behavior, both empirical evidence and practical applications of intention-based interventions have challenged the supposition that intention is sufficient to produce behavioral enactment for many, a discrepancy commonly known as the I–PA gap and the focus of this review. Empirical evidence suggests that the association between intention strength and PA is modest. For example, a meta-analysis of the theory of planned behavior, one of the most applied intention-based models in PA research, showed the correlation between intention strength and behavior was r = 0.48 (10). The relationship was further attenuated (r = 0.22) in the meta-analysis when examining change in behavior (i.e., controlling for past behavior) (10). Meta-analyses of behavioral interventions in which intention strength was included as a putative mediator have also shown modest associations (ab = 0.06) (11). Furthermore, the dose–response relationship of experimental manipulations that increase intention strength (d = 0.45 or r = 0.22) also results in much lower, and clinically less meaningful, increases in PA (d = 0.15 or r = 0.08) (12). The culmination of this evidence is that, although intention represents a meaningful link to PA, it may not be the grand mediator of PA behavior for many, as proposed in Figure 1.
Greater clarity is gained by exploring the I–PA relationship in the form of a 2 × 2 matrix that comprises decisional intention–behavior profiles of nonintenders (those without intention) who subsequently do not engage in PA, successful intenders (those with intention who subsequently engage in PA), nonintenders who subsequently engage in PA, and unsuccessful intenders (those with intention who subsequently do not engage in PA) (8). A recent meta-analysis using this 2 × 2 matrix highlighted where the discordance between intention and PA clearly lies (9). Specifically, 26% of samples were nonintenders, 4% were nonintenders exceeding intentions, 33% were unsuccessful intenders, and 39% were successful intenders (see Fig. 2) (9). Further, 72% of samples included intenders of PA, but 48% of those intenders failed to follow through with PA (9). Thus, although the presence of intention is almost always necessary to achieve PA, the chances of one following through with intention are ostensibly a flip of a coin.
Figure 2. The intention–physical activity gap. Although intention is necessary for physical activity, only about half of intenders follow through. CI, confidence interval.
These findings clearly challenge the sufficiency of theories that include intention as the sole proximal determinant of PA and raise practical and translational recommendations (13). First, given that most people intend to engage in PA, interventions focusing on building intention, as proposed by many established psychological models (5), may have limited effectiveness. A meta-analysis showed that approximately 25% of inactive people may benefit from this approach of building and forming PA intentions, but 35% of inactive people may be left out (9, 13). Second, theories focusing on behavior-change techniques (BCTs) and mechanisms of action (MoAs) for building intention may have limited applicability to those who have intention but face challenges in translating it into PA. Interestingly, such populations are comprised of those most likely seeking behavior-change support, including but not limited to the massive number of people who make New Year's PA resolutions annually but struggle to keep to these intentions (14), parents intending to support their children's PA yet falling short (15), those opting into weight loss programs (16), or even the very people who volunteer for behavior-change research trials (6).
Perhaps the most important phenomenon related to this disconnect between good intentions and poor follow through in PA underlies the drop from behavioral initiation to sustained PA behavior (17). For nearly 50 years, researchers have documented a large (approximately 50%) drop-out rate among those beginning a PA program, which is so well-known that commercial gyms predicate their business models on these high drop-out rates (18, 19). Thus, the importance of identifying what predicts the translation of PA intention into behavior is paramount for the advancement of both theory and practice.
WHAT PREDICTS THE I–PA GAP?
Correlates of the discordance between intention and PA have been well-researched over the last 20 years. A recent meta-analysis by Feil et al (9) examined methodological factors as potential moderators of the I–PA gap. Study design (e.g., longitudinal and cross-sectional), the type of intention measure applied (e.g., open-ended and fixed-graded), and the type of PA assessed did not moderate the relationship (9). However, studies using direct measures of PA and those with a higher risk of bias showed a larger I–PA gap than studies using self-reported measures of PA (likely due to common methods bias) and those with moderate risk of bias (9).
The largest review to date on moderators/predictors of the I–PA gap was conducted by Rhodes and colleagues (20). The authors evaluated 138 studies (59,661 participants) and examined 77 potential moderators/predictors across sociodemographic, health, individual, interpersonal, and environmental domains (20). The key findings are outlined in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Moderators of the intention–physical activity gap and their associations (20). The intention–physical activity relationship is moderated by demographic, personality, reflective, regulatory, reflexive, social, and environmental factors. BMI, body mass index; PA, physical activity.
Demographic Variables
Among sociodemographic and health variables, only employment status reliably moderated/predicted the I–PA relationship (20). This suggests that employed and unemployed individuals may have similar intentions, but employed individuals are more likely to act on them, resulting in a smaller I–PA gap. The finding was noted as difficult to explain because it may reflect other factors related to the sample's health profiles or contextual influences not fully captured in the studies (20). Other sociodemographic (e.g., gender, income, and marital status) or health (e.g., body mass index) variables did not moderate the I–PA gap (20). Evidence for age and education as moderators/predictors was mixed (20). Taken together, the authors concluded general support for the invariance of intention and PA relations across most sociodemographic and health variables (20). This evidence also supports the premise that the I–PA gap exists across populations, regardless of sociodemographic and health status.
Personality Variables
Some evidence suggests that individual personality traits affect the extent to which intentions are translated into PA (see Fig. 3) (20). Those higher in conscientiousness were more likely to follow through with intentions compared with those lower in this trait (20). Conscientiousness represents a tendency to be ordered, dutiful, self-disciplined, and achievement-oriented and may support adherence to one's original intentions (20). There was mixed evidence for whether extraversion moderated the I–PA gap and no overall support for other personality traits (e.g., neuroticism, openness to experience, and agreeableness) as moderators (20).
Reflective Processes
Several reflective (i.e., consciously deliberated expectations of behavioral enactment) processes have been identified as moderators/predictors of the I–PA gap (Fig. 3) (20), with characteristics of intention itself considered important predictors (6, 21). For example, the review by Rhodes et al (20) found that intention stability (i.e., participants who responded with intention scores of similar magnitude across time), intention commitment, and low goal conflict were reliably associated with a smaller I–PA gap. However, the authors noted the importance of understanding the underlying causes of intention stability, commitment, and priority (20). To this end, there was convincing evidence in the review that affective judgments (i.e., thoughts about feelings of expected pleasure from performing PA) moderated/predicted the I–PA relationship (20). By contrast, instrumental judgments (i.e., thoughts about expected utility/benefit from performing PA) did not moderate the relationship (20). These findings highlight the importance of enjoyment and pleasure in translating positive intentions into PA, presumably because these judgments create more stable initial intentions over time (22). In addition, affective judgments may be markers of hedonic motivation, which is conceived to drive behavioral action through situational cues that have been linked to pleasure via past learning experiences, thus reducing the chances of I–PA discordance (23).
Rhodes et al (20) also found that individuals with higher self-efficacy/perceived behavioral control (SE/PBC) reported larger I–PA relationships than those with lower SE/PBC. SE/PBC reflects how much individuals believe they can perform PA and, when it aligns with actual control, it increases the likelihood that intentions will translate into PA (24).
从这个意义上说,自我效能/感知行为控制(SE/PBC)可作为将意向付诸行动的机会的代理指标(23)。有趣的是,在最近一项比较成功将意向转化为身体活动(PA)者与持有积极意向但未能将意向转化为行为者的 11 项研究的元分析中,情感判断(d = 0.47)和自我效能/感知行为控制(SE/PBC)(d = 0.46)也是关键预测因子(8)。在该元分析中,工具性判断的量级明显较低(d = 0.27)(8),这进一步证明了在理解意向 - 身体活动不一致性(I–PA discordance)时,工具性判断和情感判断之间存在重要差异。
**调节性过程**
调节性过程代表用于执行意向的行为、认知和情感策略(7)。它们通常被认为是大多数专注于意向转化为行为的理论的主要特征(13)。主动(即在行为执行前制定)的行为调节策略,特别是执行意图/行动计划(如果 - 那么行动计划),在心理学中通常被理论化为连接意向 - 行为差距的关键纽带(14)。值得注意的是,Rhodes 等人(20)的综述发现,关于这些计划是否能调节/预测意向 - 身体活动(I–PA)关系的证据不一致,这表明调节性过程与某些反思性过程(如自我效能/感知行为控制)之间可能存在更复杂的潜在交互作用。尽管如此,该综述发现,总体而言,行为调节策略在正向调节意向 - 身体活动关系方面发挥了作用,而用于改变身体活动的认知策略则没有(图 3)(20)。也许,一组行为调节策略可能比任何单一策略(如计划)更能有效区分谁能将意向转化为身体活动(25)。
最近一项针对 11 项研究的元分析发现,行为调节策略(d = 0.40)在区分那些坚持进行身体活动的人与那些有意向但未行动的人方面有一定有效性证据(8)。然而,其效应量与反思性动机变量(如情感判断和自我效能/感知行为控制)相当。因此,目前行为调节在专注于意向转化为行为的理论中的突出角色仅获得了适度的实证支持(13)。一个可能的原因是,启动身体活动意向的个人比那些已经保持规律活动的人更依赖行为调节,这突出了其在早期采纳阶段的重要性(17)。例如,两项纵向研究表明,与基线时已活跃且 6 个月后继续坚持其积极意向的人(d = 0.24–0.16)相比,评估前 6 个月一直不活跃且 6 个月后成功将意向转化为身体活动的人表现出更强的行为调节(d = 0.39–0.43)(26,27)。然而,其他研究对此前提的检验结论并不一致(综述见(8))。
**社会和环境机会**
Rhodes 及其同事(20)的综述还探讨了人际关系(如社会支持、社会比较和社会压力)和物理环境(如情境、资源、设备)因素是否调节/预测了意向 - 身体活动差距(图 3)。从社会生态理论的角度来看,社会和环境机会被认为与意向等因素相互作用以确定行为(20)。尽管如此,该综述显示几乎没有证据表明社会或环境因素调节了意向 - 身体活动关系(20)。这与更广泛的发现一致,即人际关系变量通常与健康行为(如身体活动)存在微弱或较小的多元关联,这可能影响了意向如何转化为行为(28)。环境安全性、基础设施质量、美学和天气也几乎没有证据表明能调节意向 - 身体活动关系(20)。唯一的例外是环境的便利性/可及性,一些研究表明其具有正向调节证据(即可及性增加,意向 - 身体活动关系更大)。然而,总体而言,建成环境和自然环境与意向 - 身体活动关系之间似乎很少存在相互作用。
**反射性过程**
Rhodes 等人(20)综述带来的知识进步之一是对自动/反射性动机因素作为意向 - 身体活动差距的调节/预测因子进行了评估。反射性动机过程(即习得的关联、线索驱动的行为和低意识动机)在传统理解身体活动时往往被忽视(5),但通常被认为是维持身体活动的重要驱动因素(17)。该综述包含足够多的研究以评估习惯和身份在预测意向 - 身体活动差距中的作用,但习惯(即习得的线索 - 行为关联)显示出混合结果(20)。习惯理论传统上将习惯定位为意向 - 行为关系的负向调节器(随着习惯增加,意向 - 身体活动关系变小),但 Rebar 等人(29)证明,导致身体活动负向调节结果的回归中的习惯发现可能是共线性的伪影。Rhodes 等人(20)综述中修正了这一潜在伪影的研究显示了意向 - 身体活动关系的正向调节。与习惯相比,身份(即角色自我分类)是意向 - 身体活动关系的令人信服的调节因子,方向为正向(身份越高,意向 - 身体活动关系越大)(20)。这些结果与身份理论相符,其中的调节效应可能是基于身份的行为的选择偏差,因为拥有身体活动身份的人会对抓住活跃机会保持敏感,从而履行其意向(30,31)。最近一项区分成功意向者(即将积极意向转化为身体活动者)和未成功意向者(即未能将积极意向转化为身体活动者)的八项研究的元分析也支持了习惯(d = 0.59)和身份(d = 0.62)作为意向 - 身体活动差距预测因子的重要性(8)。这些效应在综述中是最大的(8),支持了反射性过程在预测意向 - 身体活动差距方面的潜在重要性。
**干预以缩小差距**
对意向 - 身体活动差距预测因子的综述突出了干预的几个关键作用机制。这些作用机制可以通过适当的行为改变技术加以影响,行为改变技术定义为“行为改变干预内容中最小的部分,可观察、可复制,且单独就具有带来行为改变的潜力”(32)。尽管一些作用机制研究不足,但目前情感判断、自我效能/感知行为控制、行为调节、习惯和身份代表了最有希望的干预目标(20)。鉴于干预参与者通常已经持有身体活动意向,确定哪些作用机制可以被修改以及与此变化相关的行为改变技术对于解决意向 - 身体活动不一致性至关重要(20)。图 4 是一个逻辑模型,旨在指导研究人员和从业者将干预内容与理论作用机制相匹配,以缩小意向 - 身体活动不一致性。该模型描绘了从 1)活跃意向(即干预登记)到 2)干预内容(即行为改变技术),再到 3)作用机制(即反思性、调节性和反射性过程),最终到 4)参与身体活动的结果的流程。
开放多媒体模态 图 4。开放多媒体模态 缩小意向 - 身体活动差距的干预逻辑模型。该模型描绘了行为改变技术如何影响反思性、调节性和反射性机制,从而将意向转化为身体活动。
**针对反思性过程**
尽管情感判断和自我效能/感知行为控制等反思性过程通常被作为加强意向形成的目标,但我们的逻辑模型(图 4)表明,在意向形成后加强这些构念对于减少意向 - 身体活动不一致性也可能至关重要。在反思性过程中,情感判断在观察性研究中与身体活动可靠相关,并体现在已建立的理论框架中(33)。Rhodes 及其同事(34)对 32 项针对成年人的干预研究的元分析显示,与对照组相比,情感判断显示出有利于干预组的积极变化(g = 0.43;95% 置信区间 [CI] = 0.26–0.60)。然而,亚组分析暗示可能存在潜在的出版偏差,因此在泛化有效性时需持谨慎态度(34)。与混合样本相比,女性中的效应更高,且不活跃参与者中的效应更大,这突出了针对不活跃人群的价值(34)。主要关注情感内容的干预最有效,这强调了直接针对该作用机制的重要性(34)。在一组子研究中,情感判断的变化与身体活动变化相关,支持了修改情感可以改善行为结果的前提。尽管有证据表明干预可以改变情感判断,但该元分析对于哪些行为改变技术驱动了变化尚无定论(34)。这可能反映了理论上与情感判断修改相关的行为改变技术使用有限,例如关于情感后果的信息、监控情感反应、身体变化、情感社会支持、社会奖励、重构社会或物理环境,或关于能力和过往成功的口头说服。仅应用了分级任务和普通社会支持(情感),且这些并未区分情感判断的变化(34)。需要针对情感判断及相关情感构念的持续干预,以确定驱动变化最关键的行为改变技术(33)。
与情感判断一样,自我效能/感知行为控制与身体活动始终相关(28)。根据 Bandura(35)的理论,自我效能可以通过四种来源受到影响:掌握体验、替代性体验、口头说服和生理/情感状态。然而,实验证据对于如何最好地改变这一作用机制显示出混合结果。例如,Ashford 等人(36)回顾了 27 项针对自我效能/感知行为控制的身体活动干预,发现其对自我效能(d = 0.16)和行为(d = 0.21)的影响适中。将障碍效能(d = 0.13)和任务效能(d = 0.21)干预分开的元分析也复制了这一结果(37)。与自我效能理论(35)相反,掌握体验并不是改变自我效能最有效的方式;积极反馈和替代性体验的影响更大(36)。Ashford 等人(36)的研究中采用特定行为改变技术的数量有限;大多数研究采用了多种来源,这可能混淆了结果。在一项针对老年人的研究中,干预增加了自我效能(d = 0.37),但没有单一行为改变技术能一致预测变化,且自我效能的改善与行为的映射较弱(d = 0.16)(38)。中介分析表明,自我效能/感知行为控制的变化解释了干预对身体活动影响的一小部分但显著部分(ab = 0.04)(11)。总体而言,干预可以可靠但适度地改善自我效能/感知行为控制,但具体负责的行为改变技术仍不清楚。
**针对调节性过程**
相当多的研究探讨了采用行为调节策略的干预是否有助于将积极意向转化为身体活动(39)。迄今为止,研究和理论主要集中在主动行为调节上,如计划、问题解决和自我监控。这些行为调节直接对应行为改变技术,使得提出实际建议比情感判断和自我效能/感知行为控制更容易。计划通常在干预中作为意向后的行为改变技术被探索,形式为行动计划/执行意图或应对计划(14)。行动计划涉及指定行为计划中的“何时”、“何地”和“如何”要素(40)。执行意图是一种将特定情境或线索与计划的行为反应联系起来的“如果 - 那么”行动计划(40)。Carraro 和 Gaudreau(41)回顾了 19 项研究,显示与对照组相比,行动计划对身体活动行为变化的影响较小。同样,关于执行意图对身体活动影响的元分析也显示了较小的效应(42)。因此,制定执行/行动计划可能导致身体活动发生微小变化,据推测这将意向与身体活动联系起来。
应对计划涉及制定计划以解决阻碍行为的潜在障碍,作为行动计划的备用方案,有助于增加成功的可能性(43)。Carraro 和 Gaudreau(41)关于身体活动中应对计划的元分析发现,与无治疗对照组相比,行为效应较小;当应对计划与行动计划结合时,效应中等。同样,Kwasnicka 等人(44)的综述得出结论,应对计划是增加身体活动的有效技术,并且在增强行动计划方面特别有效。因此,计划,特别是行动和应对方法的结合,对身体活动产生小到中等效应,并通过支持意向的主动调节帮助弥合意向 - 身体活动差距(25)。
自我监控是涉及持续意识和跟踪行为的行为调节。它是控制理论的核心构念,控制理论是理解自我调节系统的标志性理论(5,7)。尽管任何监控系统在概念上都可以应用于身体活动情境(例如日记、日历和记事本),但身体活动追踪器(例如 Apple Watch 和 Fitbit)的精巧性使得自我监控的应用更加集成和无缝。来自随机对照试验的身体活动追踪器证据通常支持身体活动的小幅增长(d = 0.27)(45),在智能手机自我监控追踪器的综述中也发现了类似结果(46)。除了数字工具外,自我监控始终与身体活动变化相关;一项针对 122 项饮食和身体活动干预的元分析发现自我监控对有效性至关重要(47)。这些发现在更新的身体活动改变策略综述中得到了复制(48)。总体而言,自我监控可靠地产生小而又有意义的身体活动增加。
尽管主动调节和自我监控对促进身体活动显然很重要,但最近的研究和理论已经考虑了反应性行为调节(即在特定情境中实施的调节)的潜力(25)。
反应性调节中最常见的策略之一包括情绪调节的内在心理战术,广义上定义为任何旨在修改情绪体验的努力(49),例如注意部署(如改变焦点、分散注意力和集中注意力)和认知改变(如观点转换和重新诠释)。在体育活动促进中,这些策略有助于在先前形成的意图受到挑战时维持对行为表现的专注,从而减少体育活动意图和行为的放弃(21,31)。最近一项荟萃分析评估了采用情绪调节策略的干预措施在成年人中改变体育活动的效果(39)。一项针对26项研究(n = 1934)的随机效应荟萃分析显示,体育活动的变化趋势为干预组优于对照组(g = 0.24;95% CI = 0.12–0.36)(39)。然而,点估计值在样本量较小、全女性样本、经过验证的体育活动自我报告测量、可行性设计以及较短的干预和随访评估中显示出了偏差(39)。因此,情绪调节干预措施可能会改变体育活动,但目前的估计值受到初步阶段研究的偏差影响。此外,与体育活动变化相关的潜在行为变更技术总体上结论不明确(39)。作者建议需要更多针对与情绪调节理论机制相一致的具体行为变更技术的干预措施(39)。针对反身性过程习惯和身份的反身性结构代表了意图—体育活动差距的最大预测因素(8)。能够修改这些中介机制的干预措施高度相关,而最近的两项荟萃分析揭示了我们在针对这些机制方面的当前成效。Ma等人(50)评估了10项以习惯为重点的体育活动干预措施及其潜在调节因素。这些研究质量较高,且在样本和传递格式上各不相同(50)。重要的是,与对照组相比,这些干预措施提高了体育活动习惯(标准均值差 = 0.31,95% CI = 0.14–0.48),尽管短期研究显示了更大的效应(50)。不幸的是,行为变更技术的亚组分析提供了有限的见解;应对计划是唯一与有效性呈正相关的行为变更技术,而社会奖励则与较低的有效性相关(50)。行为变更技术的同质性,包括习惯形成技术(如线索一致性和执行意图),可能限制了实际建议。测试仅在研究特定组中存在的行为变更技术的具体析因设计,可能有助于揭示体育活动习惯形成中最重要的行为变更技术。最近一项荟萃分析检查了改变体育活动身份及其近乎同义词的图式、自我定义和整合性调节的干预措施的有效性(51)。该分析包括了40个独立效应量的成人样本,涵盖了45个行为变更技术,以进一步探索身份干预措施的有效性(51)。总体而言,结果显示身份变化趋势为干预组优于对照组(g = 0.18;95% CI = 0.11–0.24),且无显著异质性(51)。因此,干预效应通过各种行为变更技术保持稳定,对如何改变身份提供的见解有限。值得注意的是,Michie等人(32)的身份集群中标明的五个行为变更技术(13.1至13.5)中,只有两个(13.3,不兼容信念;13.4,有价值的自我身份)在干预措施中得到应用,这限制了当前的证据(51)。作者建议进一步探索性地应用身份集群的行为变更技术(51)。结论意图—体育活动差距仍然是体育活动促进中的核心挑战。虽然意图是体育活动必要且成熟的先决条件,但许多人未能付诸行动;近一半具有积极体育活动意图的人未能跟进。因此,确定什么预测意图转化为体育活动,对理论和方法的进步至关重要。证据确定了反思性(即情感判断和自我效能/控制信念)、调节性(即计划和自我监控)和反身性(即习惯、身份)过程作为意图转化的预测因素。针对这些结构作为中介机制的干预措施,与对照组相比,体育活动变化显示小到中等效应量,但进展受到行为变更技术应用异质性的阻碍。许多研究设计包括多个行为变更技术,针对几个中介机制,而一些仍缺乏研究。缩小意图—体育活动差距需要促进情感判断和自我效能/控制信念的策略,加强行为调节,支持自动化,并使行为与身份一致。通过提供理论和证据的清晰视觉综合,本综述为研究人员和实践者提供了实际指导。未来研究使用持续实验设计,包括更精确地将行为变更技术与中介机制关联的析因研究,将对开发有效将意图转化为持续体育活动的干预措施至关重要。致谢我们感谢Henry La在共同创建图表方面的协助。本手稿的部分起草和编辑是在人工智能语言模型(ChatGPT;OpenAI,美国加利福尼亚州旧金山)的协助下完成的,以提高清晰度和措辞。未使用任何人工智能工具来创建图像、收集数据或进行数据分析。作者对所有内容承担全部责任。本文的发表并不代表美国运动医学会的背书。利益冲突和资金来源所有作者均无任何利益冲突或资金来源需要报告。